Understanding the Defendant's Statement in the Criminal Process
The video discusses the defendant's statement in the criminal process, focusing on prohibited questions, the right to silence, and the importance of the defendant's control over their declaration.
00:00:00 An overview of the key points regarding the defendant's statement in the criminal process, including the role of judges and the legal framework, as well as problematic aspects such as the right to remain silent and differences in statements.
1️⃣ The process of the accused's statement in a criminal trial is governed by legal frameworks and involves constitutional rights.
2️⃣ The declaration of the accused is a crucial step in the trial, allowing them to respond to charges and present their defense.
3️⃣ The accused has the right to choose when and how to make their statement, within the limits set by the law.
00:11:23 Declaración del imputado en el proceso penal: explanation of the defendant's rights, including the right to legal defense, right to remain silent, and right to an objective interrogation without physical restraints. The structure of the statement consists of instruction of rights, identification, narration of the alleged event, and direct questioning by the prosecutor, defense, and judge if necessary.
🔍 The defendant in a criminal trial has the right to be informed of their rights, including the right to have legal representation and the right to remain silent.
⚖️ During the defendant's testimony, the prosecutor or judge can ask them to clarify their statements, but cannot exhort them to confess or tell the truth.
🔒 The defendant has the right to a fair and objective interrogation, free from physical restraints, and in a secure environment to ensure the safety of everyone involved.
00:22:46 Summary: The video discusses the defendant's statement in the criminal process, focusing on prohibited questions in direct examination, the right to silence, and the importance of the defendant's control over their declaration. The defendant has the right to limit their statement and not incriminate themselves. The defendant's statement during the investigation phase is called indagatoria and allows for the investigation of the facts and the defendant's defense.
📌 There are certain prohibited questions and techniques in cross-examination to prevent misleading or misleading responses from the defendant.
🔒 The defendant has the right to remain silent and control what they declare during the process, as this is a fundamental part of their defense.
🔎 The defendant's statement, known as the indagatoria, is a means of investigation and allows for the exploration of relevant circumstances.
00:34:05 The video discusses the importance of the defendant's statement in the criminal process. It explains that the defendant is obligated to give a statement and highlights the principles of contradiction and knowledge of charges. It also outlines the specific procedures and rights related to the defendant's statement.
📚 The judicial system requires the declaration of the defendant in order to ensure the principle of contradiction and the right to be heard.
⚖️ The declaration of the defendant is considered an essential step in the oral trial procedure and is treated as a form of evidence.
🗣️ Special rules apply to the defendant's declaration, including the option to refuse to answer, the right to give a free and oral account, and the involvement of the defense lawyer.
00:45:28 In a criminal trial, the defendant's statement is considered as evidence and can contribute to the judge's conviction, although it is not binding. The defendant's statement is evaluated along with other evidence, applying rational judgment and reliability criteria.
🔑 The accused's plenary statement can be considered as evidence and contributes to the judge's conviction.
🔍 The information provided by the accused in the oral trial is valuable and can be analyzed and contrasted with other evidence.
⚖️ The judge must evaluate the credibility and reliability of the accused's statements, considering other evidence and legal criteria.
00:56:52 Declaración del imputado en el proceso penal: la importancia de confrontar al acusado con su declaración previa y obtener una explicación para cualquier cambio de versión. El derecho al silencio y la presunción de inocencia también se discuten.
Declarations made during the preliminary investigation should only be considered in the trial if they meet certain requirements.
When the accused changes their statement during the trial, a specific confrontation and interrogation are necessary to explain the change.
In evaluating contradictory statements or silence, the judge must provide reasons for their credibility assessment.
The right to silence and presumption of innocence should not be violated and the refusal to testify should not be treated as evidence of guilt.
01:08:17 In this video, César San Martín Castro discusses the defendant's right to remain silent and the importance of their final statement in the criminal process.
🔍 The silence of the accused does not imply guilt, but sufficient evidence is required to construct a conviction.
🗣️ The last word given to the defendant in a criminal trial allows them to present additional information for consideration by the court.
⚖️ In cases of alleged procedural violations, the concept of material defense deprivation is used to determine if a nullity exists.
Want to deep dive into this video?
