The Challenges of Building a 'Super App'
Elon Musk's ambitious attempt to create a 'Super App' faces challenges as dominant local services and payment apps prevent widespread adoption.
00:00:00 Elon Musk aims to build a 'Super App' despite previous failures. Super apps dominate in Asian countries but have not succeeded in the Western world. Can Elon Musk's app, 'X', be the exception?
🌍 Super apps dominate in some countries, but have failed in Western countries.
📱 China's WeChat is a successful super app with over a billion users.
💡 Elon Musk aims to build a successful super app called X.
00:02:43 A look at the rise of WeChat and the super app model in China, where users can pay bills, purchase tickets, play games, and more all within one app. The model has been replicated by other companies globally.
⚡️ WeChat's launch of the super app in China revolutionized the combination of payments and messaging into a single app, leading to the success of mini programs with millions of active users.
📱 The super app model quickly spread across other countries, with domestic and international companies replicating the concept to consolidate multiple services into one app.
🌍 Despite its success in some regions, the super app phenomenon failed to gain traction in many countries, particularly in the western market.
00:05:27 Exploring the failure of Western super apps and assessing Elon Musk's chances of success. WeChat and Alipay are the only successful super apps, as the model does not make sense outside of China.
💡 Attempts at building a Western super app have failed.
💡 There are three different definitions of super apps.
💡 WeChat and Alipay are the only successful true super apps.
00:08:09 Elon Musk's attempt to create a 'Super App' faces challenges as local services and payment apps dominate the market. Building a successful wallet requires a strong core payments use case, which may be difficult to achieve.
📱 The super app model consists of three types: platform-based, local services, and payments.
🌍 Platform-based super apps, like WeChat, focus on integrating various services within one app.
🚖🍕💰 Local services super apps, like Grab and Gojek, offer physical services such as ride-sharing and food delivery.
💳 Payments super apps, like Paytm, provide digital wallets and integrate various payment options.
🔖 Elon Musk aims to build a super app that focuses on the payments model and aims to become a WeChat-like platform.
💼 Considering his experience in running a payments company, Elon's strategy may face challenges in implementing a successful payments model.
00:10:51 Elon Musk is attempting to build a core payments use case within the app itself, focusing on paid subscriptions and exclusive content. However, adoption has been unimpressive, and convincing users to use the social media app for payments will be a challenge.
💼 Elon Musk's attempt to build a 'Super App' focused on in-person payments and mobile wallets.
📱 Elon aims to create a core payments use case within the app through paid subscriptions and advertising revenue share.
💳 The adoption of paid features in the app has been unimpressive, posing a challenge for convincing users to use it for payments.
00:13:33 Elon Musk's attempt to build a 'Super App' with Twitter is a risky move given the competition and the resources required for building a payments app. Integrating payment features could potentially worsen the social media app. Twitter's involvement in this venture seems unnecessary.
💡 Twitter's attempt to build a payment app instead of focusing on its core business is a massive risk due to resource diversion.
🌍 The integration of payment features into the social media app may negatively impact its user experience, as Western consumers prefer focused apps with specific functionalities.
🔧💰 Elon Musk's proposed payment app could have been developed with a fraction of the cost spent on Twitter, without the burden of a struggling social media platform.
00:16:15 Elon attempted to build a 'Super App' through Twitter, but there may have been better approaches. Despite doubts, watching people like Elon try the impossible is captivating. Check out the documentary series 'Red Atoms' on Nebula for more inspiring stories.
💡 Elon Musk's attempt to build a "Super App" through Twitter was convoluted and unlikely to succeed.
🌟 The documentary series 'Red Atoms' depicts the Soviet Union's struggles in building its nuclear program against adversity.
💰 Nebula is a platform with a wide range of exclusive educational content, ad-free and funded by subscriptions.
Want to deep dive into this video?
