Supreme Court Trial on the Ending of Decisive Vote at CARF

📺 The Supreme Court is currently reviewing actions that challenge the removal of the casting vote in the CARF.

🗳️ The casting vote, previously held by the president of the judging panel and representing the Federal Revenue, has been modified.

💼 The outcome of tax credit disputes will now be resolved in favor of the taxpayer, rather than the government.

🔍 The Supreme Court of Brazil is reviewing cases related to the elimination of the majority vote in CARF.

⚖️ There are three main arguments presented: procedural defects, imbalance in quality of judgments, and bias towards private interests.

📝 The relator, Minister Marco Aurélio, argues that the change in the rule was unconstitutional and a violation of democratic principles.

✅ The Supreme Court is considering the elimination of the voto de qualidade in the CARF.

⚖️ The Dean of the Supreme Court believes that the tiebreaker by not paying the taxes is legitimate and reasonable.

🗓️ The virtual plenary session to analyze the case is scheduled to end on April 12th.