The Significance of the Tenth Civil En Banc Plenary Session in Peru

🔑 The video discusses the importance of the tenth casatory plenary in civil matters.

💡 The plenary will address two key issues: the doctrine of building and the evaluation of evidence.

🔗 There is a connection between the two topics.

📄 The video discusses the topic of prova onus in court proceedings.

⚖️ The concept of prova de oficio is controversial among legal theorists.

🧪 Prova de oficio is a power attributed to judges, allowing them to initiate evidence on their own.

🔑 The video discusses the initiative of judges to incorporate new evidence in decision-making.

💡 There is a debate on whether judges should have the freedom to exercise their own initiative in gathering evidence.

⚖️ The goal is to establish clear criteria or rules for the judge's actions, in addition to those provided by the law.

🔍 The video discusses the concept of "el respeto al principio del contradictorio" as an epistemic control mechanism.

💡 The importance of seeking the truth and its connection to the judicial process is highlighted.

🌟 The project of reform is mentioned as a means to clarify certain points.

🔍 The first topic is about the search for truth in the legal system.

⚖️ The second topic is about the controversial issue of how to properly assess evidence in civil cases.

🔎 While there is a general formula for assessing evidence, specific criteria are not always provided in legislation, leading to diverse models and systems for evaluation.

🔍 Joint evaluation in judicial practice often used as a magic formula to cover up shortcomings in the evaluation of evidence and facts.

📚 Before jointly evaluating, there should be an analytical and historical evaluation of each fact and each piece of evidence.

👥 The Supreme Court is shifting towards controlling facts, not just aspects of law.

🔍 The convocation is a demonstration of the Supreme Court's orientation towards opening up spaces for the review of facts.

📝 It is a starting point for rethinking the legal process.

🙏 The hope is that this will be useful for future discussions.