Understanding the Flaws in Neoclassical Economics and Market Behavior
This lecture explores the limitations of the neoclassical model in explaining market behavior, including the flawed assumptions of rationality and identical consumer tastes.
00:00:06 This lecture discusses the limitations of the neoclassical model and its inability to explain rational human behavior in market settings. It also explores the conditions under which the law of demand applies to market demand curves.
The neoclassical idea of rational behavior doesn't accurately describe how people behave in reality.
Revealed preference theory only explains how an individual consumer behaves, not the market demand curve.
The conditions under which the market demand curve slopes downward are explored in the Insan and Schwanman Solder Brewer conditions.
00:06:43 This video discusses the flaws in neoclassical economics and how it models the macro economy. It also explains the concept of proof by contradiction using the example of the square root of 2.
📚 Neoclassical economists have merged microeconomics and macroeconomics, resulting in modeling the entire economy as one consumer operating in perfect competition.
⚖️ Market demand curves do not obey the law of demand, challenging the assumption made by neoclassical economists.
🔍 Using proof by contradiction, it is shown that the square root of 2 is not a rational number, leading to a discussion on rational numbers and mathematics.
00:13:17 The video discusses how the discovery of irrational numbers transformed mathematics. It also explores the conditions needed for the market demand curve to obey the law of demand.
🔑 The discovery that the square root of 2 is not a rational number transformed mathematics and led to the development of complex numbers.
📈 The law of demand holds at the individual level, but aggregation challenges its validity.
💰 To have multiple consumers and commodities, there must be different income sources and changing tastes with income.
00:19:50 This video discusses how changes in income affect the distribution of income and the assumption of identical consumer tastes to derive a market demand curve.
📊 The distribution of income and the law of demand affect the shape of the market demand curve.
💰 Neoclassical economists assume that changing prices do not affect incomes when deriving the demand curve.
📉 Individual demand curves can have various shapes, but the market demand curve can have any shape.
00:26:26 A lecture on market behavior and the limitations of classical economic theory. It discusses the need for a new, empirically-based approach to economics.
📊 The lecture discusses the complications of demand and marginal revenue curves in relation to supply and equilibrium analysis.
🧠 The speaker emphasizes the need for an empirically based approach to economics, rather than relying solely on classical theory.
💡 The lecture explores the dynamic nature of consumption and how it changes over time, considering factors such as income distribution and marketing dynamics.
00:33:00 This video discusses the flaws in the neoclassical economics concept of market demand curves and the assumption of a one big happy family in the economy.
📚 The lecture discusses the problem with neoclassical economists' understanding of market demand curves and aggregation.
💡 Neoclassical economists fail to grasp the aggregation problem, as illustrated by Paul Samuelson's flawed textbook explanations.
🤔 The lecture highlights the unrealistic assumptions made in neoclassical economics, such as assuming the entire economy acts as one big happy family.
00:39:33 This video is a lecture on market behavior in economics. It discusses aggregate demand and supply curves, rationalization of economic agents, and the difference between competitive firms and monopolies.
The aggregate demand function has no interesting properties, so assumptions need to be made to make it interesting.
Combining preferences of individuals to represent the entire region as a single economy is not possible.
The demand curve in standard microeconomics is not accurate as individuals cannot be utility maximizers.
The supply curve in standard microeconomics is only true for a horizontal demand curve.
Monopolies have a higher price and result in welfare loss.
Want to deep dive into this video?
